|

NEWS
ABOUT CHILE

Chile in the international press
Politicians attempt to woo Hispanic vote
John Authers, Financial Times
August 31st
Don Francisco, Hispanic America's most popular
broadcaster, landed a blow for Spanish-language TV this month
when his programme won the ratings battle for young adult viewers.
Don Francisco Presenta was more popular among
18- to 49-year-olds than any English-language offering in its
time slot, even its biggest rival, the crime drama Law &
Order. It was the first time Spanish programming had achieved
this feat in the nation's largest media market.
The milestone, much celebrated at Don Francisco's
network, Univision, the biggest US Spanish-language network,
came during the quietest period of the year. But Univision has
more viewers than any English-language networks in Los Angeles,
Miami and San Antonio, and already had plenty to crow about.
In the 12 months to July this year, its primetime viewership
among those between 18 and 49 rose by 18 per cent.
Others are competing. Azteca America, backed by
the Mexican broadcaster TV Azteca, and NBC's Telemundo both
offer a similar diet of news, variety shows, Mexican soap operas
and Latino sports (particularly Mexican soccer).
The rise of television in Spanish is the most
obvious symptom of a growing “Hispanic market” in
the US, to which both marketers and politicians are desperate
to appeal. But the “Hispanic” community is diverse.
Does it really make sense to talk about a single “Hispanic
market,” or one “Hispanic vote”? And is Spanish
the best language to reach them?
Sergio Bendixen, a Peruvian and an influential
pollster and consultant to several Democrat politicians, can
trace an emerging “Hispanic” identity. “Hispanics
come from many different countries, and they have very different
legal status in this country. . . . What holds us together is
a culture that works to live rather than one that lives to work.”
This is seen as in contrast to an “Anglo”
culture where self-image is linked to how much money people
make and to how much they work. Mr Bendixen cites Univision
as an example. “There's a message throughout their programming,
and that is that they emphasise the cultural differences, and
the importance of holding on to them.”
In focus groups, young Hispanics who speak English
and have never been to their parents' home country still proudly
call themselves Latino. “They say: ‘We enjoy life
more. We have stronger relationships. We give friendships more
importance. We stay closer to our families.' They are much more
able to show their emotions and are very passionate about things.”
This, Mr Bendixen says, is “what joins the second-generation
Hispanic in Texas and a recent migrant who just arrived in Orlando
or New York”.
Others disagree. Andre Pineda, a Californian pollster,
the son of immigrants from Costa Rica and Nicaragua whose wife
was born in Mexico, says: “It's not Hispanic surnames
that matter most here. What matters more is country of origin,
or how long they've been in the US, or which generation, or
which language they choose to use.”
Cubans, for example, are notoriously more conservative
than other Hispanics. But, he says, Cubans in “Generation
1.5” those born abroad, who arrived in the US before their
10th birthday approach politics differently from their parents.
“Their obsession with Fidel Castro is not there. They're
trying to get through college and go to professional school
and so on. What does Castro have to do with any of that?”
Si! TV, which started broadcasting last year as
the latest entrant to vie for Hispanic viewers, was founded
upon exactly this demographic insight. All its programming is
in English.
Even Spanish-language stations now carry English
advertising. According to Carlos de la Garza, who heads advertising
sales for Azteca America: “Latinos like to go to a film's
opening weekend. It's a status symbol. And they don't want to
see a movie like Brad Pitt's Troy dubbed into Spanish.”
The makers of Troy understood this - they ran
English commercials during the advertising breaks for Mexican
soccer games and soap operas.
This truly bilingual community creates difficulties
for marketers and politicians alike. Azteca is now launching
its soap operas simultaneously on both sides of the border,
and Femsa, the Mexican brewery that makes Sol and Tecate, tailors
its marketing of lager to different consumers.
Anglos and established Hispanics are targeted
with bottled beers at a premium price, advertised in English,
while Tecate is aimed at immigrants. As drinking beer from a
can is expensive in Mexico, where most beer is drunk from returnable
glass bottles, Tecate in California is marketed in Spanish,
and sold in cans to aspirational migrant workers who want to
show that they have arrived as rich Mexicans, and can afford
canned beer.
Political appeals to Hispanic voters have yet
to show such subtleties. Democrat strategists say President
George W. Bush's success in gaining 42 per cent of the Hispanic
vote last year was in part because most Latinos lived in non-competitive
states, without big “get out the vote” campaigns.
But New Mexico was harder to explain. The state
is more than 40 per cent Hispanic, but swung to Mr Bush last
year despite the presence of Bill Richardson, the state's Democratic
governor, who is himself Hispanic. According to Mr Pineda, the
Democrats made a basic mistake in approaching Hispanic New Mexicans,
many of whom are of Mexican origin but whose ancestors have
lived in the state for more than a century. “We have to
get [beyond] the idea that Spanish is the path to the Latino
vote. Only 18 per cent of US Latinos are voters.”
He added: “Unlike Hispanics as a whole,
72 per cent of Latino voters were born in the US, and only 9
per cent come from Spanish-speaking households. Two-thirds per
cent say they watch more English than Spanish.” The Democrats
might have done better speaking in English.
Peru in a glass: A pisco primer
JACOB GOLDSTEIN, The Miami Herald
August 25th
It may be possible to understand pisco without
considering the Spanish conquest of South America, the Chilean
invasion of Peru and the first Peruvian driver to finish the
Paris-Dakar road rally.
But if you ask Ari Loebl about the potent brandy
known chiefly for its role in the pisco sour, that is more or
less the route his answer will take. The route will be long,
and it will be framed by a grand yet simple rhetorical flourish.
''Why do we claim that pisco is Peruvian?'' he
will ask. ``It is history.''
That question (and its answer) go to the heart
of a Peruvian complaint against Chile, which manufactures and
exports more pisco than Peru -- a fact that has inspired not
only much gnashing of teeth among the Peruvian cognoscenti but
a case before the United Nations-sponsored World International
Trade Organization.
The WIPO ruled on July 14 that brandy can be called
pisco only if it comes from Peru. Two weeks later, on Peru's
independence day, pisco spewed from the fountain at the center
of Lima's main square.
TRADING PLACES
Ari Loebl is in the pisco business. Although he and his wife,
Elena, relocated to South Florida in 1986 with their son, Herbie,
they still do business in their native Lima. The family distributes
American and European food products in Peru (''Hershey, Wrigleys
. . . big names,'' Elena says) and Peruvian foods in the United
States and Europe.
In the early 1970s, Loebl, a fan of car racing,
met Coco Corbetto, the first Peruvian ever to finish the Paris-Dakar
rally. Corbetto ran his family's business, Pisco Montesierpe.
''His pisco was very good, but he didn't know
how to sell it,'' Elena says.
The Loebls began selling Montesierpe in Peru in
1999. Last year, they began importing it to the U.S.
Since then, Herbie has spent countless hours schmoozing
liquor store owners and bartenders -- buying drinks, asking
what they know about pisco, leaving them free bottles. He says
he now sells to about 250 South Florida customers.
Herbie, who is 25 and could be cast in a movie
as an earnest young man on the make, is particularly pleased
with the work of Leonardo Lopez, an Argentine bartender at Sushi
Samba Dromo on Lincoln Road. Lopez might mix a pisco lychee-tini
or a pisco with watermelon and mint.
He also makes a fine pisco sour, shaken rather than the traditional
frappe. The drink is three parts pisco, two parts citrus (lemon,
lime or sour mix), one part sugar, a dash of bitters and a raw
egg white (or pasteurized, powdered egg white, depending on
the bartender).
There is something to be said for watching a bartender
crack an egg and separate the white into the pint glass in which
he's mixing your drink. In a small way it conveys the sense
of living on the edge, of literally drinking in what the world
has to offer, that is part of the pleasure of getting drunk
in a bar.
Though pisco is made only of grapes, its smell
and taste are reminiscent of a very mellow tequila, and the
pisco sour could be a cousin of the margarita, with a little
meringue on top courtesy of the agitated egg white.
''What gets you is the foam,'' says Herbie. ``You
never had a drink with foam on it.''
SPANISH CONQUEST
Ari Loebl's story of the meaning of pisco begins in the 1530s,
with the Spanish conquest of the Incas.
''When they came to Peru they found there were
no grapes,'' he says. ``There was no wine. There's no Spaniard
who will have lunch without wine.''
The conquerors discovered their Old World grapes
grew well in a valley south of present-day Lima. The valley
was full of birds, and came to be called Pisco, from pisscu,
the native word for ''little bird.'' (This according to a Peruvian
tourism brochure titled ''Pisco Belongs to Peru.'' The obvious
subtitle -- ''and not to Chile'' -- is left unstated.)
In time the name of the valley was also applied
to the brandy distilled from the local wine.
According to Loebl, pisco made its way to Chile during the War
of the Pacific in 1879. ''The Chileans, when they invaded Peru,
they liked the pisco and they took it to Chile,'' he says. (For
their part, the Chileans claim they began making brandy in the
17th century and selling it as pisco in 1871, eight years before
the war.)
Chilean pisco is aged in wood barrels, which give
it a brownish tint, and mixed with water to lower the alcohol
content. Peruvian pisco is kept in glass or steel containers
(''It has to be completely transparent,'' Loebl says) and sold
undiluted. Peruvian pisco is 76 to 96 proof; most Chilean piscos
are 60 to 90 proof.
The recent WIPO ruling is unlikely to affect pisco
sales in the U.S., which is not a signatory to the treaty governing
country-of-origin labeling for spirits. The battle between the
two countries seems likely to slog on.
Like the French, who insist that champagne can
only be made in Champagne, the Peruvians say pisco must come
from Pisco (or thereabouts).
The website of the Peruvian embassy in London
offers a 14-page 'defense of the Peruvian denomination of origin
`pisco' '' that includes a detailed history of grape cultivation
in Peru as well as a list of 17 pisco-related laws, resolutions
and decrees.
The Chileans seem to favor a live-and-let-live
approach.
''Shared with our Peruvian neighbours,'' says
the website of Chile's U.S. embassy, ``pisco is a grape brandy
of high alcoholic grade.''
''Each one has its clientele,'' says Marcel Encina,
owner of Sabores Chilenos on Flagler Street. ``The Chileans
like the Chilean. The Peruvians like the Peruvian.''
If nothing else, the fight has raised pisco's
profile back home.
Drinking it ''just recently has become an issue
of patriotism,'' Herbie says.
''Five years ago, of every 10 cocktails that were
sold in Peru, nine were whiskey and one was pisco,'' says Ari.
``Today it's exactly the opposite.''
Capital Formation Gives Big Lift to Chile's GDP
The Wall Street Journal
August 24th
SANTIAGO, Chile -- Chile's gross domestic product
rose 6.5% on the year in the second quarter, the Central Bank
reported. The figure is above the 6.1% revised growth figure
for the first quarter, which the bank originally reported as
rising 5.7% on the year, but in line with previously released
economic-activity data.
"Overall, this is a very constructive and
balanced set of real sector figures -- broad-based and balanced
growth drivers with a very sound demand-side composition,"
said economist Alberto Ramos at Goldman Sachs in New York.
In the first half, GDP grew 6.3% on the year,
well above the bank's 5.5%-6% estimate issued in late May and
moderately below the torrid growth of late 2004.
The Central Bank estimates GDP growth of 5.3%-6.3%
this year, but will publish a revised outlook next week.
"The main booster of this result was gross
capital formation," up 26% on the year in the first half,
the bank said. Most of the rise in capital formation stemmed
from investment in machinery and equipment, which surged 42.6%
in the first half, and construction, which increased 13.6% on
year in the period, the bank said.
American Creates Vast Park in Chile
Reuters en Los Angeles Times
August, 22th
CALETA GONZALO, Chile — He spent more than
$30 million and wrangled with the Chilean government and public
for eight years, but a former American clothing magnate-turned-conservationist
has realized his dream of transforming his vast lands in southern
Chile into a nature sanctuary.
In a ceremony at the gateway to his rainy Patagonian
wonderland, Douglas Tompkins, co-founder of clothing company
Esprit, donated more than 714,000 acres of almost untouched
forest to a Chilean foundation that will run South America's
biggest nature preserve.
The Pumalin Park Nature Sanctuary is a rugged
land of mossy trails, steep mountains, deep fjords and clear
rivers, with camping and cabins for tourists who fly or boat
in from the city of Puerto Montt, 75 miles away.
"I especially salute your perseverance,"
Chilean President Ricardo Lagos told Tompkins at Friday's ceremony.
"I never imagined a project to protect our natural resources
could have so many obstacles."
Four years ago, Tompkins threatened to abandon
the park after lawmakers and business and civic groups objected
that his land purchases limited economic development in the
remote area and threatened national security.
Tompkins said he fell in love with southern Chile's
dramatic landscapes as a youth and began buying the land 15
years ago. Tompkins' Conservation Land Trust and his wife Kristine's
Patagonia Land Trust have purchased more than 2 million acres
in Chile and Argentina.
Education Minister Sergio Bitar said he took on
the sanctuary as a pet project and worked to turn the tide of
negative opinion in Chile, where most people thought of Tompkins
as the man who tried to cut the country in half by buying up
land.
The decree forming the sanctuary puts the land
in the hands of a national foundation and guarantees government
access for roads and power lines.
Among the former detractors at the ceremony was
Sen. Sergio Paez, who represents the southern part of Chile's
Tenth Region and had criticized Tompkins for allegedly forcing
settlers to sell him their land.
"I talked to a lot of people and many people
did get good money for their land and they were not taken advantage
of, which was what I had feared," Paez said.
Tompkins and his wife will be on the seven-member
board that runs the sanctuary, along with religious, government
and academic representatives. His land trust will provide most
of the approximately $700,000 a year it costs to administer
the park.
Victory for democracy
OUR OPINION: CHILE RIDS ITSELF OF LAST VESTIGES OF PINOCHET'S
MILITARISM
The Miami Herald, editorial
August 19th.
The people of Chile, a nation often cited as Latin America's
model democracy, quietly took another important step this week
to restore their country's constitutional equilibrium. Just
one month before the 32nd anniversary of the coup that overthrew
the elected government of Salvador Allende and ushered in a
military dictatorship led by Gen. Augusto Pinochet, full control
of the military was once again placed in the hands of civilian
authority. This is a significant political and historical milestone
that deserves to be cheered.
By a resounding vote of 150-3, the Chilean Congress voted to
discard anti-democratic provisions inserted into the constitution
at Gen. Pinochet's insistence after a new constitution was put
into effect in 1980. This occurred at a time when the general
ruled Chile with an iron fist and brooked no real opposition.
Among other things, these archaic provisions allotted appointed
seats in the Chilean Senate to retired military and police commanders
and denied the president the power to fire military commanders.
The purpose of these provisions was to ensure the continuing
power of Gen. Pinochet and his military cadre when the general
was obliged to relinquish power to civilians after his defeat
in a plebiscite in October of 1988. No matter who was elected
by the people to run the country, the military would hold a
trump card.
It has been nearly 20 years since that famous voto del no --
when Chileans said No to Gen. Pinochet's dictatorship and voted
to return to the path of democracy. It has taken this long for
Chile to rid itself of these odious remnants of the dictatorship
precisely because they cemented Gen. Pinochet's position as
a powerful member of the Senate -- also guaranteed by a tailor-made
constitutional provision -- and unfairly gave the military political
power that it was loath to surrender.
It is a measure of the political maturity of the Chilean people
that the nation did not rush to change the constitution in the
early years of the transition to democracy. This could have
precipitated a dangerous political crisis. This week's decision,
which won support from President Ricardo Lagos and the opposition,
signals that the last vestiges of Pinochetism are finally being
relegated to the history books, where they belong.
Gas ring
Chile's search for reliable suppliers
The Economist
August 19th.
OVER the next couple of years Chile is likely to be Latin America's
fastest-growing economy, as it was for much of the 1990s. But
there is one big potential brake: energy. With little oil or
coal of its own, Chile imports two-thirds of its energy, relying
especially on Argentina's natural gas. Some $4 billion has been
invested in gas pipelines and gas-fired power plants. Until
recently, Chile was importing 20m cubic metres of Argentine
gas per day. This provided a quarter of central Chile's electricity
and almost 60% in the north.
But Argentina's government has frozen the price of gas at home:
consumption has soared and investment fallen. Since last year
it has imposed unilateral cuts in gas exports to Chile of 20%
(and at times 50%). Chile has avoided power cuts, mainly because
heavy winter rains boosted hydroelectric output. But it urgently
needs more reliable suppliers.
One solution might be Bolivia, which has South America's largest
gas reserves after Venezuela. But Bolivia still smarts at Chile's
annexation of its mineral-rich coastal territory in a 19th-century
war. It refuses to sell gas to Chile.
So Chile is looking elsewhere. First, ENAP, the state oil company,
plans to award a contract in October for the supply of liquefied
natural gas (LNG) and a $400m re-gasification plant near Santiago.
A second, more ambitious, plan is for a single “energy
ring” in South America's southern cone which would incorporate
gas from Peru's Camisea field. This would use existing pipelines
across the southern cone. It would add at least one more, along
the Pacific coast from Peru to Chile.
Mooted at a meeting of Mercosur, the region's putative common
market, in June, this plan is gathering momentum. A legal framework
for it should be drawn up by the end of the year. One obstacle
is Chile's quarrel with Peru over their maritime border. But
supply cuts for nationalist reasons would be less likely if
they also affected Argentina and Brazil, and the project would
include some form of supply insurance.
The bigger question is whether the “ring” is the
best design for energy integration. The 1,200km (750-mile) pipeline
from Peru to northern Chile could cost up to $1 billion. A possible
extension to Santiago would increase demand, but over a distance
at which it becomes cheaper to import liquefied gas (indeed
Peru might be a supplier for the ENAP plant). Transport costs
would make Peruvian gas uncompetitive in Argentina. And Camisea
may not have enough gas to supply the southern cone as well
as the home market and planned LNG exports to North America.
The main purpose of the “ring” appears to be to
coax Bolivia (an observer at the talks) into bigger gas exports.
“It's amazing how transforming this into a multilateral
issue has cut through bilateral difficulties,” says Rudolf
Araneda, a manager of a Chilean pipeline. Bolivia has resumed
talks on a second pipeline to Argentina (potentially freeing
up more Argentine gas for Chile) which it broke off earlier
this year because of political turmoil. The “ring”
means that Bolivia would no longer hold all the cards in the
southern cone's power game. But much will still depend on Bolivia's
presidential election in December.
Pinochet's wife gets bail, but not son
Augusto Pinochet's wife, Lucía Hiriart, was granted freedom
on bail in a tax evasion probe, but a divided court denied bail
to their youngest son, Marco Antonio Pinochet.
Miami Herald
August, 12th.
SANTIAGO, Chile - (AP) -- A court on Thursday granted freedom
on bail to the wife of Gen. Augusto Pinochet but kept his youngest
son on jail, one day after both were indicted and arrested as
accomplices in a tax evasion probe related to the former dictator's
multimillion-dollar fortune overseas.
Pinochet's 82-year-old wife, Lucía Hiriart,
will remain a bit longer in Santiago Military Hospital, where
she has been detained, so that she can undergo some medical
tests, the hospital announced Thursday.
In the case of the former dictator's son, Marco
Antonio Pinochet, the court voted 2-1 to keep him in jail because
he might be considered ``a risk for society.''
As soon as the court's 3-0 decision to release
Hiriart was announced, aides for Pinochet rushed to the bank
to deposit the $3,600 bail.
Doctors said Wednesday that Hiriart was being
treated for headaches and high blood pressure. The hospital's
communiqué Thursday said that although she has ''evolved
in a satisfactory manner,'' her blood pressure is still high.
Hiriart and the young Pinochet were indicted and
ordered arrested Wednesday by Judge Sergio Muñoz as part
of his investigation into the multimillion-dollar accounts owned
by Pinochet at banks in the United States and other countries.
The existence of the account was disclosed by a U.S. Senate
committee investigating the Riggs Bank of Washington.
Pinochet, 89, said in a statement Wednesday that
he put the ''savings of my entire life'' into overseas accounts
because he expected that after he left office he would be the
target of ``persecution and political harassment.''
Muñoz has indicated he plans to try Pinochet
himself in the case, and has already succeeded in having the
Santiago Court of Appeals strip the former ruler of his immunity
from prosecution, a ruling that has been appealed by his defense
before the Supreme Court.
Muñoz has estimated Pinochet's fortune
abroad at $27 million. The judge calculated that Pinochet failed
to pay the equivalent of $9.8 million in taxes and said that
his wife has not filed a tax return since 1998. Pinochet said
he has already paid those taxes.
Police in Chile Detain Pinochet's Wife
and Son
in Fraud Inquiry
By Larry Rohter, The New York Times
August, 11th.
RIO DE JANEIRO, Aug. 10 - The wife and younger
son of Gen. Augusto Pinochet were in police custody in Santiago,
Chile, on Wednesday after a judge ordered them detained in connection
with a tax fraud investigation of secret bank accounts that
General Pinochet, the former Chilean dictator, opened in an
American bank.
Lucía Hiriart de Pinochet and Marco Antonio
Pinochet are charged with being General Pinochet's accomplices
in a decade-long scheme to shift millions of dollars, whose
origins are also being investigated, to safe havens abroad.
In recognition of her fragile health, Mrs. Pinochet, 82, was
being held in the Military Hospital in the Chilean capital,
where her husband visited her on Wednesday afternoon.
"This is like a bullet in the head,"
said Augusto Pinochet Jr., the couple's elder son, as he arrived
at the hospital. He was convicted of fraud last year and fined
in a case involving stolen cars. "What do they want? There
is no respect for anything or anyone on our side."
In June, General Pinochet was stripped of immunity
from prosecution so that tax fraud charges might be filed against
him. That decision has been appealed to the Chilean Supreme
Court, which in the past has ruled that Mr. Pinochet, 89, who
was in power from 1973 to 1990, is too feeble to stand trial
in connection with human rights violations.
Addressing reporters, President Ricardo Lagos
cited Wednesday's indictments as proof that "in Chile,
all citizens are equal; no one is above the law." Because
of the corruption accusations against him, General Pinochet's
stature in Chile has declined even among former supporters,
and there were no protests or statements of support for him
on Wednesday from active duty military officers.
The Pinochet family's secret accounts came to
light 13 months ago, the result of a United States Senate committee
inquiry into possible money laundering at Riggs Bank in Washington.
At that time, American investigators concluded that General
Pinochet had hidden up to $8 million in six accounts there,
some opened with his wife under aliases.
Since then, however, a Chilean prosecuting judge,
Sergio Muñoz, and the investigators working for him have
concluded that the amounts involved are actually much larger.
In a recent court filing, he calculated that General Pinochet
had more than $17 million in more than 100 bank accounts in
the United States, Chile and other countries.
Under Chilean law, Judge Muñoz has until
Saturday to conclude his inquiry, and some additional indictments
are possible. On Monday, he interrogated six former military
officers who worked on General Pinochet's staff, reportedly
in an effort to determine if money from a secret government
fund was illicitly transferred to General Pinochet's personal
accounts abroad.
In remarks to reporters in Santiago, General Pinochet's
lawyer, Pablo Rodríguez, said the indictment, though
"expected," was "a huge mistake and a tremendous
injustice." Mrs. Pinochet, he maintained, "had practically
no involvement in the matters Judge Muñoz is investigating"
and merely received without question the money her husband passed
on to her, "as spouses do with their partners."
But the judge's 27-page ruling, based on three
interrogations of Mrs. Pinochet, concluded that she "at
all times had knowledge" of the movement of her husband's
fortune and "received direct benefits" from the joint
accounts. As for Marco Antonio Pinochet, he "cooperated
in the management of the funds that Augusto Pinochet Ugarte
maintained abroad, an activity in which he used false documentation,"
the judge ruled.
A Writer Whose Posthumous Novel Crowns
an Illustrious Career
LARRY ROHTER, The New York Times
August, 9th.
SANTIAGO, Chile - Even before his death two years ago at 50,
Roberto Bolano was emerging as his generation's premier Latin
American writer. But with the posthumous success of "2666,"
an extravagantly encyclopedic 1,119-page novel that traverses
two continents and eight decades, Bolano's reputation and legend
are in meteoric ascent.
To younger readers and writers, Bolano, a Chilean who died in
a Barcelona hospital while awaiting a liver transplant, is a
cult hero cut down, like some rock star or movie idol, as he
was reaching his prime. In little more than a decade, he produced
a torrent of novels, short stories and essays that chart a path
distinct from the "Boom generation" of Latin American
writers before him.
"Bolano's genius is not just the extraordinary quality
of his writing, but also that he does not conform to the paradigm
of the Latin American writer," said Ignacio Echeverria,
former literary editor of El País, Spain's leading daily.
"His writing is neither magical realism, nor baroque nor
localist, but an imaginary, extraterritorial mirror of Latin
America, more as a kind of state of mind than a specific place."
Since its publication late last year, "2666" has won
nearly every literary award for which it is eligible, most recently
the municipal prize here in Bolano's native land. It would be
the favorite for the Rómulo Gallego prize, the most prestigious
in Latin America, except that Mr. Bolano won it for his last
novel, "The Savage Detectives," and is not eligible.
Divided into five sections that Bolano first envisioned as separate
novels, to be published one a year, "2666" begins
with the hunt for a writer who has disappeared. But the search
for the writer converges with the efforts of police confronting
a serial killer who preys on female factory workers in a Mexican
border town.
"Roberto emerged as a writer at a time when Latin America
no longer believed in utopias, when paradise had become hell,
and that sense of monstrousness and waking nightmares and constant
flight from something horrid permeates '2666' and all his work,"
said the Argentine novelist Rodrigo Fresana. "His books
are political, but in a way that is more personal than militant
or demagogic, that is closer to the mystique of the beatniks"
than the "Boom."
Bolano also differs from the generation of writers preceding
him in that his national identity is fluid. Whereas Gabriel
García Márquez of Colombia, Mario Vargas Llosa
of Peru and Carlos Fuentes of Mexico all identify closely with
their native lands in their important works, Bolano makes his
protagonists vagabonds who move from country to country, usually
on some quest doomed to disappointment.
"He's not really from any one place, but is a sort of international,
post-nationalist writer with strong emotional ties to Chile,
Mexico and Spain," said Natasha Wimmer, who is translating
"The Savage Detectives" into English. "He's not
just steeped in his own national literature and drama, but is
more wide-ranging and global, especially in his later books,
and language-wise he definitely draws on the colloquialisms
and slang of all three countries." In his last interview,
published by the Mexican edition of Playboy magazine, Bolano
said he regarded himself as "a Latin American," adding
that "my only country is my two children and perhaps, though
in second place, some moments, streets, faces or books that
are in me."
His early years were spent in southern and coastal Chile, by
his own account a skinny, nearsighted and bookish but dyslexic
child. As a teenager, though, he moved with his family to Mexico,
dropped out of school, worked as a journalist and became active
in left-wing political causes. He returned here just before
the 1973 coup that installed Gen. Augusto Pinochet in power,
and, like many others of his age and background, was jailed
but, as he told it, was saved when two former classmates serving
in the national police recognized him and authorized his release
following a week in prison.
After an interlude in El Salvador, spent in the company of the
poet Roque Dalton and the guerrillas of the Farabundo Martí
National Liberation Front, he returned to Mexico living as a
bohemian poet and literary enfant terrible - "a professional
provocateur feared at all the publishing houses even though
he was a nobody, bursting into literary presentations and readings,"
his editor, Jorge Herralde, recalled.
He finally made his way to Spain, where he married and settled
in a small town on the Mediterranean coast near Barcelona working
as a dishwasher, a campground custodian, bellhop and garbage
collector, while he wrote.
Mr. Bolano thought of himself primarily as a poet, and a 20-year
collection of his verse was published in 2000 under the title
"The Romantic Dogs." He turned to narrative fiction
"and abandoned his parsimonious beatnik existence,"
Mr. Herralde said, because the birth of his son in 1990 made
him "decide that he was responsible for his family's future
and that it would be easier to earn a living by writing fiction."
As regards his native country, which he visited just once after
going into exile, Bolano had conflicted feelings. It was surely
not by accident that the main garbage dump where many of the
murdered women in "2666" are found is called "El
Chile," or that he named his son Lautaro, after a leader
of the Indian resistance to the Spanish conquest here.
Bolano is also notorious in Chile for his fierce attacks on
Isabel Allende and other members of the literary establishment.
"He didn't fit into Chile, and the rejection that he experienced
left him free to say whatever he wanted, which can be a good
thing for a writer," said the Chilean novelist and playwright
Ariel Dorfman. Of Latin America's writers, Bolano most admired
Borges. The first of his novels, "Nazi Literature in the
Americas," published in 1996 and soon to be available in
English, can be read as a homage to Borges.
A voracious reader, Bolano was also familiar with Anglo-American
literature, and was fascinated by such genre writers as James
Ellroy, Philip K. Dick and Cormac McCarthy. "Everything
he writes seems to have some riddle in it that is a reference
to something else," said Deborah Treisman, fiction editor
at The New Yorker, which plans to publish a Bolano short story
later this year. "You get a definite sense of the wide
reading he had done and feel this sort of allusive quality."
In "2666" Bolano works some ofthe same geographic
territory as Mr. McCarthy - the arid frontier between Mexico
and the United States - but in the more hallucinatory fashion
of Mr. Ellroy. Though the novel starts and ends in contemporary
Germany, the focus is on the murders of scores of female factory
workers in the imaginary border city of Santa Teresa, a plot
line modeled on similar killings that have occurred in recent
years in Ciudad Juárez.
The reasons for the book's unusual title remain a mystery even
to Bolano's closest friends. But there are oblique references
in his writing indicating that Bolano thought of that year as
a sort of apocalypse. Thus far, Bolano is little known in the
English-speaking world and most of his work is not readily available.
But the critics and editors familiar with the two small, early
novels that New Directions has published in translation, "Distant
Star" and "By Night in Chile," or who have read
him in French, German or Italian translations have been unusually
enthusiastic about his work. Susan Sontag called him "the
most influential and admired novelist of his generation in the
Spanish-speaking world."
Over the next few years, more Bolano will be translated into
English. In addition to the 622-page "The Savage Detectives"
and "2666," the rights to both of which were recently
acquired by Farrar, Straus & Giroux, all his other novels
are to be translated, and a collection of short stories called
"Last Evenings on Earth" is to be published early
in 2006. "We want to do everything, because he is just
a mesmerizing writer," said Barbara Epler, editor in chief
of New Directions.
Bolano was extraordinarily prolific, but Mr. Herralde, his Spanish
editor, said that not much remains unpublished: a volume of
poetry tentatively called "The Unknown University"
and one more collection of short stories. Bolano joked about
the "posthumous," saying the word "sounds like
the name of a Roman gladiator, one who is undefeated,"
and would no doubt be amused to see how his stock has risen
now that he is dead. Still, Mr. Fresan said that "Roberto
was one of a kind, a writer who worked without a net, who went
all out, with no brakes, and in doing so, created a new way
to be a great Latin American writer."
An American in Chile Finds Conservation
a Hard Slog
By Larry Rohter, The New York Times
August 7, 2005
REÑIHUE, Chile - Douglas Tompkins first
fell under the spell of Chilean Patagonia's lush forests and
rushing streams as a backpacking teenager from New York. Today,
40-odd years older and much, much richer, he may well be the
region's biggest individual landowner, and its most controversial
foreign presence.
His holdings in this realm of snowcapped peaks
and wind-whipped shores are larger than Rhode Island and include
tracts that timber, electric power and agricultural interests
covet. But instead of moving to chop, dam and dig, Mr. Tompkins
has turned his properties into nature sanctuaries, open to the
public but with strict limits on use, that he has said repeatedly
he hopes to donate to the people of Chile. If they can be persuaded
to accept his offer.
In so insular a society, far-fetched explanations
for Mr. Tompkins's presence here have flourished like moss.
Some have suggested that he wants to turn Patagonia into a nuclear
dumping ground, others speculate that he wants to seize control
of water supplies in a world with a growing thirst, and there
have even been accusations that Mr. Tompkins, a buttoned-down,
gray-haired WASP, has acquired the land as the site for a new
Jewish state.
Over the years, Antonio Horvath, a conservative
senator who represents the region just south of here, has been
one of Mr. Tompkins's leading critics, suggesting that he is
just the latest in a long line of foreign adventurers with extravagant
designs on Patagonia. He dismisses some allegations against
Mr. Tompkins as "extreme ultranationalist postures,"
but says his presence does raise legitimate issues of sovereignty
and development.
"If I were to go to the United States and
buy a big area of Florida as an environmental preserve and tell
people they can't go here or there, I think the U.S. would kick
me right out of there," Mr. Horvath argued. "Every
nation wants some degree of protection of its territory, and
Chile is no different."
Just the reserve here where Mr. Tompkins lives
much of the year, known as Pumalín Park in honor of the
pumas that roam the park's virgin forests, occupies 1,153 square
miles. All told, he and his wife, Kristine McDivitt, a former
chief executive officer of the Patagonia retail chain who is
wealthy in her own right, own more than 2,000 square miles of
wilderness real estate dotted across southern Chile, either
directly or through foundations they control.
"We want to do something good, but you've
got to be very naïve and out to lunch to think that certain
sectors of society are not going to put up resistance,"
Mr. Tompkins said in a rare interview on a typically squally
day here at his remote homestead at the head of a fiord. "If
you're not willing to take the political heat, then you shouldn't
get into the game of land conservation, especially on a large
scale."
Raised in Manhattan and Dutchess County, Mr. Tompkins,
62, became interested in the outdoors as a teenage rock climber
in the Shawangunk Mountain Range, in the Hudson River Valley,
and visited Patagonia for the first time as "kind of a
ski bum" in 1961. He later founded The North Face, an outdoor
apparel company, and the Esprit line of clothes, which he sold
in 1990 for a price reported to be more than $150 million, giving
him the means to indulge his fascination with the wilderness.
Mr. Tompkins has the lean and weathered look of
the outdoorsman and a direct and blunt style that Ms. McDivitt,
gentler and more cheerful, tempers. Their home here, which they
designed themselves, is built in a simple but elegant style
that recalls the Pacific Northwest, open and airy with plenty
of windows to take advantage of a view that includes a volcano
off in the distance.
One of the reasons he chose Chile as the base
of his conservation efforts, Mr. Tompkins said, was a dynamic
free-market economy that is unique in Latin America, with few
government restrictions on the purchase or development of property.
But the tradition of philanthropy that accompanied the growth
of American capitalism has not taken root here yet, and that,
Mr. Tompkins's local supporters say, has worked to his disadvantage.
"Because he is a North American doing this
for such a strange purpose, for conservation, the assumption
is that he must have hidden intentions, a secret agenda,"
said Rodrigo Pizarro, the director of Terram, a leading environmental
group in Chile. "If he were buying the land for profit,
like all the other foreigners do, no one would be raising any
questions."
Pumalín Park actually bisects Chile, running
from Corcovado Gulf to the Andean mountain border with Argentina.
Mr. Tompkins and his wife have acquired an additional 1,129
square miles of land in Argentina, mostly in the Patagonia region
there, which only adds to nationalist anxieties, here and there.
Business interests here and in the United States
have also sought at public events, in publications and on Web
sites to portray Mr. Tompkins and the nonprofit Foundation for
Deep Ecology he established in 1990 as environmental extremists,
even crackpots. He shrugs that off as part of a smear campaign,
but makes no apologies for his belief that human interference
with nature has provoked looming global disaster.
"To me, we are on a runaway train, heading
for a cliff with nobody at the controls," he said. "It
has to do with our economic model and our ecological illiteracy,
our overexpansion, our dangerous technologies that have damaging
effects on ecosystems, our consumption patterns. It's an interminable
list of environmental catastrophes and encroaching populations,
and you have to ask: Where are we going? What is enough? What
are the limits?"
Chilean ecologists agree with his objectives,
but not always with his methods, which reflect his hard-charging
background in the American business world rather than the chummy,
close-knit world of politics in this nation of 15 million people.
"The project itself is a very good one, a
model for others to follow, but Tompkins himself sometimes doesn't
help much," Mr. Pizarro said of Pumalín Park. "He
has an entrepreneurial mentality, wants to do his business his
way and can be a bit disdainful of the way things are done in
countries like ours, which has led him to make a lot of errors
in communication."
In the late 1990's, Mr. Tompkins's efforts to
join the north and south sections of Pumalín Park by
buying the 125-square-mile tract separating them were blocked
by the Christian Democratic government then in power. Even though
he was willing to offer the best price, the Roman Catholic university
that owned the parcel sold it to a Spanish-controlled power
company.
His relationship with the current, nominally Socialist
government, which leaves office early in 2006, has been cautiously
friendly. At the start of this year, an area he owned south
of here, known as Corcovado and Tic-Toc, was designated a national
park, and plans are under discussion to expand it to include
what would be Chile's first marine sanctuary.
These days, Mr. Tompkins also has a message that
may calm his critics: he has reached his limit and does not
intend to buy more land. "We have a number of ventures
that we are working on, and those are going to take the rest
of our lives to finish," he said, clearly interested in
his legacy.
Carlos Weber, the director of the National Forestry
Corporation, Chile's equivalent of a national park service,
said that "though the local authorities still have in their
heads a model based on settler colonies that raze the forest
to plant potatoes and raise animals, what Tompkins is doing
offers the best opportunity for sustainable development in that
region."
"He is little appreciated, understood or
welcomed in Chile today," Mr. Weber said, "but I predict
that 30 years from now, after people's thinking has matured
and they see results, no one will be against him."
Chile Is Hot
By Michael Franz, Food Section, The Washington Post
July 27th.
During the past two decades, the wine business has become extremely
competitive and truly global. Countries that could recently
have been dismissed as winemaking upstarts have become worldwide
contenders, and today the most elite regions face stiff competition
from many quarters. This was perhaps demonstrated most strikingly
when Australia surpassed France in wine exports to the United
States in 2003. Since then, competition for shares in world
markets has increased, and even an export powerhouse like Australia
must now worry about the challenges posed by Argentina and Chile.
These two countries enjoy a powerful combination: very low production
costs and superb conditions for growing grapes. Widely regarded
as good sources for low-priced bottlings, both have recently
proved that they can produce reds that rival the world's best
in terms of quality while undercutting them in price.
This has led naturally to accelerated development of the industries
in both countries, with the delightful result that new wines
seem to arrive here almost weekly from either Argentina or Chile.
I've recently been scrutinizing them to learn whether they will
diminish or enhance the two countries' stature as wine producers.
As you may have seen in my columns of June 29 and July 13, I've
found the newcomers from Argentina extremely impressive. I can
now report that Chile's newest exports are likewise remarkably
strong.
As in the case of Argentina, the best wine flowing our way from
Chile remains red. Cabernet sauvignons and Bordeaux-style blends
are the best of the best, but impressive improvements are also
being made with carmenere. This grape was virtually lost in
France during the famous Phyloxerra blight of the late 19th
century but was rediscovered just over a decade ago in Chile.
Chilean vintners are learning how to deal with carmenere's late-ripening
peculiarities, and lower-priced bottlings are becoming more
consistent even as high-end renditions are attaining indisputable
greatness.
You'll see that some whites also have earned recommendations
below, and there's good reason to believe that Chile has edged
ahead of Argentina where whites are concerned. To the best of
my knowledge, the wines reviewed here are all the first or second
vintage available in our area. They are reviewed in order of
preference, with parenthetical indications of growing regions,
approximate prices, importers and local distributors:
RED WINES
Purple Angel (by Montes) (Colchagua Valley) 2003 ($48, TGIC
Importers/available in August from F.P. Winner in Maryland):
This is the new state of the art in carmenere. Dark, densely
concentrated and packed with powerful flavors, it is nevertheless
as impressive in complexity as power. Notes of licorice, cocoa,
wood smoke and minerals lend interesting accents to the core
of blackberry fruit. Carmenere has its detractors both within
and beyond Chile, but this wine should reduce their ranks.
MontGras (Colchagua Valley) Minquén Mountain Vineyard
2002 ($32, Palm Bay/National): This blend of 95 percent cabernet
sauvignon and 5 percent malbec shows marvelous complexity in
a restrained, sophisticated mode that places it in a league
with wines costing over $50. Lovely notes of cedar, dark cherries
and blackberries, dried herbs, tobacco leaves and leather are
detailed and expressive.
Casa Lapostolle (Requinoa Vineyard, Rapel Valley) Syrah "Cuvee
Alexandre" 2003 ($23, Marnier-Lapostolle/ Washington Wholesale):
Massively concentrated but marvelously lush and soft, this is
already beautifully integrated and will continue to develop
for years to come.
Sincerity (Colchagua Valley) Merlot/Cabernet Sauvignon 2003
($17, Royal Imports/National): This delicious wine deserves
your attention even if you weren't looking for one that was
crafted from organically grown grapes. A blend of 55 percent
merlot and 45 percent cabernet sauvignon, it is packed with
ripe, rich, vivid fruit, and it also offers a softness that
seems unusual in a wine packing such deep flavors. Most wines
costing $30 should seek cover when this one enters a room.
Morande (Maipo Valley) Carmenere "Edicion Limitada"
2002 ($20, TGIC/Country Vintner): Exotic and interesting, this
features a solid core of blackberry fruit with accents of licorice,
dried herbs, roasted meat and spices. Also excellent is Morande
(Maipo Valley) "Edicion Limitada" Cabernet Franc 2003
($25).
MontGras (Colchagua Valley) "Quatro" Reserva 2004
($15, Palm Bay/National): This internationally styled wine packs
a wallop of fruit that is framed with a dose of spicy oak. Made
from 35 percent cabernet sauvignon, 28 percent malbec, 22 percent
merlot and 15 percent carmenere, it offers excellent value for
the price.
Also recommended: Morande (Maipo Valley) Cabernet Sauvignon
"Vitisterra Grand Reserve" 2002 ($16, Morande USA/Country
Vintner), Morande (Maipo Valley) Carmenere "Terrarum Reserve"
2003 ($13, Morande USA/Country Vintner) and 2 Brothers Winery
(Colchagua Valley) Syrah 2003 ($12, Billington/Winebow).
WHITE WINES
Montes (Leyda Valley) Leyda Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc "Limited
Selection" 2004 ($16, TGIC/F.P. Winner in Maryland and
Country Vintner in D.C. and Virginia): With flashy aromas and
flavors of grapefruit and freshly cut grass, this beautifully
balanced sauvignon joins Terrunyo Sauvignon Blanc in the sweepstakes
for South America's finest white wine.
Sincerity (Casablanca Valley) Chardonnay 2004 ($17, Royal Imports/National):
Fleshy and full of flavor, this chardonnay is substantial and
satisfying but so well balanced with subtle oak and fresh acidity
that it never seems heavy or tiring to drink.
Cousiño-Macul (Maipo Valley) Sauvignon Gris 2004 ($11,
Billington/Winebow): Sauvignon Gris is a very rare variety thought
to have originated in the Graves district of Bordeaux. This
rendition is medium-bodied and capable of holding its own with
relatively rich dishes, but the citrus-flavored fruit is so
fresh and well-braced by acidity that it can also be enjoyed
as a simple sipper or partner for shellfish.
Cult's Enclave in Chile, Guns and Intelligence
Files
LARRY ROHTER, The New York Times
June 17th, 2005.
RIO DE JANEIRO, June 16 - The authorities in Chile
searching for victims of Gen. Augusto Pinochet's dictatorship
who are said to be buried at the enclave of a secretive, apocalyptic
religious cult of German émigrés have unearthed
a large cache of weapons and intelligence files.
"This arsenal is going to end up being the biggest ever
found in private hands since the restoration of democracy in
1990 and in the history of Chile," the deputy interior
minister, Jorge Correa Sutil, told reporters on Wednesday. "Believe
me, what has been discovered so far is of a dimension that can
only be explained in a military context."
The enclave, Colonia Dignidad, was founded in
southern Chile in 1961 by Paul Schäfer, a former Nazi Luftwaffe
medic turned fundamentalist preacher. He fled around 1997 after
being charged with the sexual abuse of more than two dozen boys
in his care. He was convicted in absentia of pedophilia, arrested
in Argentina in March and sent back to Chile, where he is now
in prison, facing charges of kidnapping, forced labor, fraud
and tax evasion.
Colonia Dignidad enjoyed official protection during
the 17-year dictatorship of General Pinochet, and had close
relationships with the Chilean Army and the state intelligence
agency, known as DINA.
According to a 1991 government report on human
rights abuses, Mr. Schäfer allowed DINA agents to hide
political prisoners in the enclave and may have taken part in
torturing detainees.
Human rights advocates in Chile said they hoped
the files found at the site would help explain the relationship
between Mr. Schäfer and state security forces, as well
as the fates of some Pinochet opponents.
The material is being examined by a judge and
has not yet been made public, but Chilean news reports said
the documents included files on hundreds of people that the
government and Colonia Dignidad regarded as enemies. More than
250 people still live at the enclave.
Among the cult's other victims may have been Boris
Weisfeiler, an American mathematics professor who disappeared
20 years ago while hiking near Colonia Dignidad. A Chilean military
informant later provided an account, found plausible by the
American Embassy, saying Dr. Weisfeiler, a Russian-born Jew,
had been killed on Mr. Schäfer's orders.
The weapons seized include machine guns, rifles,
rocket launchers, grenades and mortars. Some were said to be
of World War II vintage, and were accompanied by manuals written
in German; others were more modern.
The discovery may solve another mystery: From
the mid-1970's, the United States and other countries cut off
weapons sales to the Pinochet dictatorship, which nonetheless
managed to stay well armed. Diplomats and rights groups have
long suggested that Colonia Dignidad acquired weapons for the
Chilean military through trading companies that the sect controlled.
Citing military sources, the Chilean daily La
Nación reported Thursday that the arms at Colonia Dignidad
were buried there between 1976 and 1978, when Chile nearly went
to war with neighboring Argentina in a border dispute.
Government officials said the discovery of the
arms would strengthen their case against Mr. Schäfer and
associates who are also in jail by giving prosecutors grounds
to invoke a racketeering statute. "Colonia Dignidad was
an illicit association dedicated to committing sexual, tax and
economic crimes and had a paramilitary purpose," Mr. Correa
Sutil said.
New OAS chief ready for challenges aplenty
In an interview, Chilean diplomat José Miguel Insulza
recognized he has entered a minefield at the Organization of
American States, starting with worsening finances. But he insisted
he could reach out to all from north to south.
JANE BUSSEY, The Miami Herald
June 8th, 2005.
As a Chilean exile living in Mexico, José Miguel Insulza
helped found one of Latin America's first U.S. studies centers
outside Cuba. His understanding of the United States may have
served him well before his election as secretary general of
the Organization of American States, when Washington favored
first a Salvadoran, then a Mexican for the post.
''Look, I have a daughter who was born here in the United States,''
Insulza said, adding that, like many exiles who have moved from
country to country, ``I am good at making friends.''
But while the Chilean politician could brush off Washington's
initial opposition, he faced a quick baptism by fire at the
three-day OAS General Assembly meeting in Fort Lauderdale.
Not only is political unrest erupting in the region, the OAS
faces a financial crisis.
In an interview, Insulza acknowledged that reordering the OAS'
priorities is among his first tasks.
''I've discovered the OAS does so many things,'' he said. ``It's
too many missions.''
Insulza, who turned 62 last week, started out as a Christian
Democrat in Chile, then served as a Foreign Ministry advisor
in the government of the late Chilean Socialist President Salvador
Allende. After Allende was overthrown by Gen. Augusto Pinochet
in 1974, Insulza left Chile, living six years in Spain before
going to Mexico.
He helped found the Center for U.S. Studies at Mexico City's
Center for Economic Research and Teaching.
''We decided it would be a good idea to carry out studies on
the United States,'' Insulza said, adding that many in Latin
America and the Caribbean fail to grasp that neither the American
public nor government is monolithic.
RETURNED HOME
Insulza returned to Chile after democracy was restored and has
participated in every government since then.
'He sort of became a `minister for life' in Chile because his
political skills are so gifted; he is widely liked and he has
key networks,'' said David J. Rothkopf, author of Running the
World: The Inside Story of the National Security Council and
the Architects of American Power.
''He's going to need all those skills,'' said Rothkopf, a former
Clinton administration Commerce Department official who has
known Insulza for many years.
At the OAS meeting, one of Insulza's strategies was to extend
his network. He spent hours listening -- for example, sitting
through a two-hour meeting Saturday where Caribbean officials
and U.S. lawmakers shared views on bilateral issues.
Just as Insulza shrugged off any lasting implications of Washington's
initial support of former Salvadoran President Francisco Flores
and Mexican Foreign Minister Luis Derbez for the OAS post, he
deflected criticism about OAS inaction in the troubled spots
across the hemisphere.
''We are going through a period of tests for democracy,'' Insulza
said, adding the challenge was trying to find a nonintrusive
way to assure that governments are not only elected democratically
but also rule democratically.
But he drew a line around the crises in different countries
facing threats to political stability and criticism of OAS performance.
The Bolivian government, whose president, Carlos Mesa, offered
his resignation this week, had not asked for OAS intervention,
and Ecuador needed more time to work out its recent change of
government, he said.
He also noted the opposition had made few formal concrete complaints
in Venezuela, where President Hugo Chávez was elected
and reaffirmed in a recall vote, but where the opposition insists
the country is sliding into authoritarian rule.
UP TO THE TASK
Insulza insisted he was up to the challenges facing the OAS
and the hemisphere.
''I have been working in negotiations all my life,'' Insulza
said, adding that talks would fail unless opposing sides were
willing to compromise. ``You have to have at least a spark of
hope.''
On Haiti, Insulza said he saw some possibility of a political
dialogue. He pledged that the OAS would help to keep that country
from sliding into a situation where elections could not be held.
''All of these issues require political leadership,'' he said.
``I hope the political role of the OAS will be recognized.''
Moisés Naím, editor of Foreign Policy, likened
Insulza's role to the head fireman whose own firehouse needs
urgent attention: ``He has a dual challenge. He has a region
in increasing political disarray and an organization that is
very weak financially and operationally.''
Weak deal puts spotlight on OAS chief
Andres Oppenheimer, The Miami Herald
June 8th, 2005.
It's now up to you, Mr. Secretary General. As expected, the
34-country Organization of American States annual meeting failed
to create a formal early-warning system to prevent new dictatorships
in the region. Now, the collective defense of democracy will
pretty much depend on your leadership.
Judging from the draft final resolution that circulated late
Tuesday, at the end of the OAS three-day foreign ministers'
meeting in Fort Lauderdale, Latin American countries significantly
watered down a U.S. proposal to give the OAS greater powers
to put joint pressure on hybrid democracies, such as those in
Ecuador, Nicaragua and Venezuela, to respect the rule of law.
While the draft final resolution is written with so many caveats
that it allows all sides to claim victory, it will not go down
in history as a turning point in the struggle against oppression.
Fears in Latin America and the Caribbean of U.S. intervention
under the guise of defending democracy prevailed over fears
of a spread of totalitarian rule in the region.
Before we get into what was approved, let's look at the original
U.S. proposal: It called on newly elected OAS Secretary General
José Miguel Insulza to draft ''a plan of action'' with
the ''input of civil society'' to strengthen the 2001 OAS Democratic
Charter. This would have given human rights groups, for instance,
a formal channel to draw OAS attention to government abuses
before they result in a break of democratic rule.
The charter, in its current form, calls on the OAS to ostracize
governments that seize power in coup d'états, but is
vague about democratically elected governments that assume near
absolute powers, closing down congress or cramming the supreme
court.
In its present form, there is little the OAS can do in a country
such as Venezuela, where President Hugo Chávez recently
packed the Supreme Court with 17 loyalists, in effect taking
over the judicial system, or taking over the country's electoral
tribunal.
Under the U.S. proposal, the OAS meeting would have agreed that
countries ``must govern democratically, fully respecting the
rule of law.''
Well, that language was not apparent in the draft that was scheduled
to be approved late Tuesday. The paragraph demanding that elected
governments rule democratically was gone altogether.
Instead of a ''plan of action'' to create an early-warning system
with the help of ''civil society'' to protect democracy, the
text only asks the OAS chief ''to make proposals for cooperation
initiatives.'' And even that, ``within the principle of nonintervention.''
U.S. officials say the draft final resolution advances the cause
of democracy.
''We are quite satisfied with this proposal,'' Roger Noriega,
the State Department's chief of Western Hemisphere affairs,
told me late Tuesday. ``It represents a consensus that the organization
needed to be more proactive, and that the secretary general
is charged with proposing new tools [to defend democracy].''
In an apparent jab at Venezuela, Noriega added that ``there
are several countries that probably didn't want any sort of
resolution of this kind.''
Other diplomats added that Venezuela joined the consensus because
it could live with the final text and didn't want to be isolated.
Chilean Foreign Minister Ignacio Walker, whose country drafted
the final resolution, told me that it was a compromise between
what the Bush administration wanted and Venezuela was willing
to accept. Which was not much. So, as I anticipated in Sunday's
column, all sides will be able to read whatever they want into
the new draft resolution.
My conclusion: The OAS' wishy-washy draft final resolution puts
the spotlight on Insulza. He will not have an explicit mandate
to move against democrats-turned-dictators, but he will have
some leeway ``to make proposals.''
That may not be too bad: a veteran former Chilean interior and
foreign minister, Insulza has been a committed human rights
and pro-democracy activist throughout his life. Now, he has
to move quickly and boldly, or the OAS will become even more
irrelevant than it has been lately.
From Thousand-Year-Old Sentinel to Traffickers'
Booty
LARRY ROHTER, The New York Times
June 3rd, 2005.
ALERCE, Chile - The majestic tree that gives this
town its name is one of Chile's principal national symbols.
Streets, schools, suburban housing developments, hotels, gas
stations, taxi fleets and even a record company and a brand
of cellphone - all invoke and honor the towering and sturdy
"sequoia of South America," as the alerce is sometimes
called.
But here in Alerce, as in many other parts of
southern Chile, there are scarcely any alerce trees to be found
these days. Predatory cutting and burning in defiance of laws
meant to protect the species have reduced its range and numbers
by half and created a lucrative black market in which alerce
timber can fetch as much as $5,000 per cubic yard, if successfully
spirited abroad.
"The corruption is tremendous, involving
very important people," said Adriana Hoffman, a former
Environmental Protection Agency director. "There is always
plenty of talk about saving the alerce, but nothing gets done
and as a result, we are losing part of our patrimony. What is
going on is truly scandalous."
Despite its resemblance to the North American
redwood, the alerce (pronounced ah-LER-say) is actually a relative
of the cypress, with a tough, water-resistant reddish-brown
wood that makes it much sought-after for use in building construction
and furniture making.
Slow-growing, largely because it favors soils
poor in nutrients that other trees shun, it nonetheless grows
to a height of 165 feet or more and a width of 15 feet, and
some trees in protected areas are more than 3,600 years old.
Since 1975, the export of alerce timber from Chile
for commercial purposes has been banned under the Convention
on International Trade in Endangered Species. To further protect
the species, Chile in 1976 also approved laws that declared
the alerce a "national monument" and prohibited the
cutting down of any live trees.
But those regulations contained a loophole that
loggers were quick to exploit. Since it is legal to harvest
dead trees killed off by fire, lightning or disease, traffickers
have been clandestinely helping the process along, environmental
advocates say, in hopes of reaping big windfalls.
Most often, loggers simply strip trees of their
bark or set forest fires to scorch them and make them eligible
for the death certificates that are required before they can
be cut down and trucked to sawmills. But the traffickers have
also been known to "strangle" alerces with metal rings
placed tightly around the trunk.
On a recent cold and drizzly Saturday morning,
José Darío Cárcamo, 68, and his son and
grandson were scavenging for the remnants of trunks in what
had once been a grove of alerce trees here. Their plan was to
recover as many stumps as they could with their axe and power
saw and then sell the wood, either to neighbors for fuel or
to local artisans who prize the alerce as the raw material for
carved souvenirs or musical instruments. "When I was a
young man, it seemed that there were still alerce forests everywhere,"
said Mr. Cárcamo, a former woodsman. "Now my grandson
has only this, and God only knows what will be left for his
grandson."
Government officials maintain that environmental
groups here and abroad are exaggerating the threat. They argue
that alerce stocks remain plentiful and that the official policy
is working better than the alternatives suggested by critics.
"The alerce is not going to be wiped out
this year or next, or in the next thousand years," Carlos
Weber, director of the National Forestry Corporation, the government
agency that oversees all aspects of Chile's forest management,
said in an interview in Santiago. "We're not talking about
50 or 100 trees left, we're talking about hundreds of thousands
of acres, far above what the market demands each year."
In an effort to safeguard the alerce, Chile has
set up a network of national parks and other protected areas.
But the government has crippled the environmental crimes division
of the national police, and environmental advocates say they
are worried at other signs of a lack of resources and political
will to guarantee that the law is obeyed.
"It's an absurd responsibility and raises
the question of whether the government is serious about enforcing
environmental laws in southern Chile," said Aaron Sanger,
the representative in Chile of Forest Ethics, an American environmental
group. "The government has one ranger for every 900,000
acres in that region, so it is kind of hard for that ranger
to do a good job of detecting illegal logging in these remote
places."
Environmental groups charge that the illegal traffic
in alerce wood is controlled by a mafia that has connections
to powerful politicians. Last year, a judge near here received
death threats after she began an investigation into charges
that a federal senator had improperly pressured Mr. Weber to
issue logging certificates to favored constituents.
More recently, the mayor of Fresia, west of here,
Nelson Schwerter, was arrested and accused of being a middleman
in an alerce-smuggling scheme. He has accused judicial authorities
of a political vendetta, but five woodcutters have identified
the mayor as the person to whom they sold illegally logged alerce.
Much of the alerce shipped abroad has been tracked
to places like Britain and Japan. "The alerce is mixed
with other woods that are not on the protected list, and the
customs people are none the wiser," said Dr. Hoffman, now
the director of Defenders of the Chilean Forest, a leading environmental
group. "There is little control and even less knowledge."
Yet in spite of the high price that alerce commands
on the black market, commercial loggers have shown little interest
in replanting the tree, for obvious economic reasons. Pine and
eucalyptus grow fast enough that they are ready for cutting
in as little as 20 years, while the alerce requires 1,000 years
or more.
China in new Latin American foray
Geoff Dyer in Shanghai, Financial Times
June 1st, 2005.
China stepped up its interest in Latin America's natural resources
yesterday when China Minmetals Corporation signed an investment
and supply deal for copper with Codelco of Chile which could
be worth up to $2bn.
In the latest overseas foray by a Chinese company in search
of raw materials, Minmetals, the state-owned group, will initially
invest $550m to obtain a 50 per cent stake in a joint venture
with Codelco, the state-owned Chilean mining group. As well
as provisions for further Chinese investment in copper mines
in Chile, the deal also gives Minmetals a long-term supply contract
of 55,000 tonnes of copper over the next 15 years.
China has been scouring the world to sign up raw materials for
its rapidly growing economy, especially since Chinese demand
began to feed into rapidly rising commodity prices around three
years ago.
China consumes around 25 per cent of the copper in the world
and its demand is expected at least to double by the end of
the decade, supplying huge investments in construction, infrastructure
and power plants.
Last year Chile, the biggest producer of copper, sent 18 per
cent of its output to China, its biggest customer. The deal
will be of huge interest in other Latin American nations with
natural resources. Although China's emergence represents a huge
opportunity and Chinese politicians have pledged billions of
dollars in investment in visits to the region, there has been
scepticism about these promises.
Juan Villarzu, chief executive of Codelco, said: "The alliance
will bring significant benefits and will assist us in developing
our copper projects through a new source of financing."
Codelco invests around $1bn a year in developing new deposits,
but analysts say it will have to invest more heavily if it is
to meet increases in global demand.
The deal, which will be financed by China National Development
Bank, also gives Minmetals an option to buy 25 per cent of the
Gaby mine, which is expected to produce around 150,000 tonnes
of copper cathode annually from 2008.
Mr Villarzu also said Codelco planned a public offer of at least
24 per cent of the Gaby project by 2009. Japanese companies
are also said to be interested in forming such joint ventures
with Codelco. Zhou Zhongshu, president of Minmetals, said that
despite the deal with Codelco, the Chinese company was still
interested in investing in Noranda, the Canadian copper and
nickel group, Reuters reported.
Growth and the Poor
Editorial, The New York Times
May 25th.
Last year should have been a good one for Latin
America's poor; the region's economies grew by 5.8 percent.
Yet outside Chile, Latin America's high growth rate is not cause
for rejoicing. In places with relatively egalitarian income
distribution, growth helps everyone. But in unequal countries,
where the poor get only a few cents out of every new dollar,
growth bypasses the poorest. Latin America is the world's most
unequal region. That means growth will not reduce poverty unless
Latin American governments redirect it to the poor.
The first thing they must do is keep growing.
Chile's achievements are in part the product of sustained growth.
Unfortunately, most countries in Latin America are growing not
because they have improved productivity, but because of the
rise in the price of oil and other commodities, quick booms
that lend themselves to quick busts.
Many countries also are carrying debt loads far
above what is considered sustainable and spend a big chunk of
their treasury on servicing their debts. For three very poor
countries, Honduras, Nicaragua and Bolivia, the international
banks and their members are reducing debt, although not enough.
But there is no help in sight for heavily indebted Uruguay,
Peru, Argentina, Brazil and other countries.
Latin American nations also typically take in
far too little in taxes. To reduce poverty with what they do
have, Latin American countries would do well to follow the model
set by Chile, which has cut extreme poverty by 65 percent since
1990 by carefully targeting its spending. Chile makes direct
payments to poor households. It has invested in rural primary
education and helps buy housing for the poorest people. These
programs have been successful because Chile is well governed
enough to measure accurately which families need help and deliver
it with little corruption.
Some other countries have similar programs. Since
1997, Mexico has helped more than four million of the poorest
families keep their children in school, eat better and stay
healthier. In many countries, these programs need closer oversight
to keep local politicians from siphoning off aid. But in general,
such targeted help can make a difference. In Mexico, it is a
safety net for the most marginalized. With sustained growth,
however, such programs could help lift millions of people out
of poverty.
Secretary General called capable, impressive leader
The Miami Herald
May 25th.
Question: The OAS General Assembly is holding
its annual meeting June 5 to 7 in Fort Lauderdale, where discussions
will focus on ''delivering the benefits of democracy.'' Is the
OAS, under new Secretary General José Miguel Insulza,
up to the task? How can the OAS foster democracy in the region?
Answer from César Gaviria, chairman of
Hemispheric Partners, former OAS secretary general, and former
president of Colombia: José Miguel Insulza is without
a doubt the appropriate person to lead the OAS given the current
state of affairs of the Americas.
He is an accomplished individual, with extensive
public experience and broad knowledge of hemispheric affairs,
resulting, in part, from his time at the Chilean foreign ministry.
He has, in addition, a character that will allow
him to act with the independence that is necessary to face the
democratic crises that threaten the political stability of the
region and the significant achievements we've reached in the
reinforcement of democratic values.
He possesses an impeccable track record for the
respect of human rights. He will be able to implement the broad
and enriched agenda set by the presidents' and prime ministers'
summits.
He will also push the OAS to be at the vanguard
in fortifying collective action to deal with the challenges
of globalization and to make the organization more inclusive
toward the hemisphere's marginalized citizens.
He will work tirelessly toward the integration
of the Americas.
Reshuffling the electoral cards
The Economist
May 19th.
A surprise presidential candidate may signal a
new era in Chilean politics
UNTIL last week, Chile's opposition parties were
pretty much resigned to losing the next presidential election,
due in December, and seeing the centre-left government coalition
take a fourth term in office. But now, following a rebellion
in the National Renewal (RN), the smaller of the two main opposition
parties, the race has been thrown wide open.
Divisions within the opposition alliance—an
uneasy marriage between the RN and the more right-wing Independent
Democratic Union (UDI)—are nothing new. The RN has long
been angered by the perceived steamrolling tactics of its more
disciplined and dogmatic ally. It is also frustrated by the
lacklustre performance of Joaquín Lavín, hitherto
the opposition's presumed joint presidential candidate, who
almost defeated President Ricardo Lagos in 2000, but has since
lost much of his popular appeal.
The RN nevertheless surprised everyone when, at
a meeting on May 14th called to endorse the UDI's Mr Lavín,
it voted overwhelmingly to proclaim one of its own former leaders,
Sebastián Piñera, as its presidential nominee.
A successful businessman worth an estimated $1.3
billion, Mr Piñera has the advantage of being able to
finance his own campaign. His opposition to General Augusto
Pinochet in the late 1980s also makes him more acceptable to
centrist voters, whereas the UDI remains tainted by its association
with the former dictator.
Could Mr Piñera win? His aides predict
that in the first round of voting he will come second to Michelle
Bachelet, the main government contender, forcing a run-off which
he could win by picking up Mr Lavín's votes and those
of centrist voters nervous about Ms Bachelet's socialism. But
could he rival her charisma?
Whatever the outcome, Mr Piñera's candidacy
signals a welcome end to the division of Chile's political parties
along the fault line of those who opposed or supported the Pinochet
dictatorship.
Park at world's southern tip recovers from fire
Katie Burford, The Boston Globe
May 17th
TORRES DEL PAINE, Chile (Reuters) - It took a
month and 800 firefighters to put out an immense wildfire earlier
this year in remote southern Chile's Torres del Paine national
park, world renowned for its awe-inspiring granite spires and
glaciers.
Now, near the southern tip of the world where the growing season
is compressed into a few months, authorities have begun the
long process of helping nature heal from the park's worst fire
in decades, started when a Czech tourist's camp burner blew
over.
Tourism officials, meanwhile, are assuring nervous tour operators
from France to Japan that Chile's most famous park is still
a rugged backpackers' paradise. Tourism pumps an estimated $75
million a year into Chile's extreme south.
"Something that man caused, man can also fix," said
Marco Cordero, regional director for Conaf, Chile's forest service.
Immediate concerns are that erosion could alter the park's brilliant
turquoise lakes, invasive plant species could gain a foothold
or endangered wildlife could be forced outside the park's protective
boundaries to forage for food.
As a token of goodwill, the Czech government contributed about
$185,500 toward the recovery, which is expected to cost $7 million.
Preserving this pristine hinterland in the heart of Patagonia,
a loosely defined region that encompasses southernmost Chile
and Argentina, is about more than aesthetics.
"Tourism for the Magellan region is one of the main sources
of revenue," said Miguel Angel, regional director for Chile's
Sernatur tourism department.
Torres del Paine is Chilean Patagonia's headline attraction,
but the Straits of Magellan, Tierra del Fuego, Cape Horn and
Antarctica are other popular destinations.
Most that journey to this far-flung, glacier-encrusted region
expect to encounter its legendary wind. It forces trees to grow
sideways and has merited a mention by every prominent chronicler
to pass through in the last 500 years.
The wind frustrated the efforts of firefighters gathered from
all over Chile and Argentina to put down the fast-moving blaze,
which seemed to send fingers out in all directions.
Authorities point out that only a fraction of the park burned
-- 45 square miles of 935 square miles total -- and this was
more than a mile from the park's signature spires, which jut
from plains in a cluster like a prairie Atlantis.
Still the damage is startling. Travelers on the park's easternmost
road drop over a hill to find themselves suddenly surrounded
by a barren moonscape. In sections, charred ground stretches
for as far as the eye can see.
The fire, which began on Feb. 17, hit at the peak of the park's
four-month tourist season, which starts in December, the middle
of the southern-hemisphere summer.
Tourism officials say they have not seen a unusual dip in visitors,
which number about 100,000 a year from 80 different countries.
As a precaution, they put the word out at travel fairs around
the globe that Torres del Paine is still very much worth the
trip.
ABOUNDS WITH WILDLIFE
Native people believed the peaks, which soar as high as 10,000
feet (3,050 m), were warriors turned to stone by an evil spirit.
Starting in the early 1900s the surrounding land, cursed by
many a settler as worthless, was used for ranching, until 1959
when it was declared a national park. Tourism started to hit
its stride in the '90s.
Outside Patagonia's protected areas large sheep farms still
operate and overgrazing of the pampa is a major concern of environmental
groups. The wildfire that devastated Torres del Paine also burned
15 square miles of adjacent private ranchland.
The park abounds with wildlife -- ostrich-like nandu, Andean
condors, llama-like guanaco, Austral parakeets, flamingos, puma
and the endangered huemul, a member of the deer family. The
only known fatalities of the fire were a handful of guanaco.
The first stage of the 12-year fire recovery plan involves filling
in trenches, dug as a barriers to contain the fire; building
dikes to prevent erosion; and collecting seeds to use for reseeding
next season. The government is compensating ranchers whose land
is being grazed by displaced wildlife.
SYMBOLIC PARK
Although Czech tourist Jiri Smitak has said he deeply regrets
the fire, many Chileans were incensed that he only received
a $200 fine. Lawmakers called for tougher penalties and the
State Defense Council filed a suit against Smitak seeking damages.
National pride in the park runs deep but since it is not connected
to the rest of Chile by road, the park is expensive to reach
and only about a third of Torres del Paine visitors are Chilean.
Most come from the United States or European countries. Visitors
fly in to an airport about a four-hour drive south of the park.
Cordero said various organizations from around the globe have
offered to help with funds or expertise. "For the whole
world, Torres del Paine park is something of an emblem,"
he said.
Peru's collective air rage
Financial Times, Observer section
May 16th
Peruvians love to tell visitors what's wrong with
their country. Of course, if others find fault, it's a different
story - particularly if they come from Chile, Peru's rival to
the south.
So when it emerged last month that Lan, Chile's
biggest airline, had shown an in-flight video depicting Lima
as a squalid and dirty city with vagrants urinating in rubbish-strewn
streets, the capital's residents were somewhat chagrined.
Lan claimed it had bought the video - meant to
highlight "adventure" tourism - sight unseen from
a company in California.
With an eye on next April's elections, Peruvian
politicians lined up to express their indignation. Congress
even hauled in Emilio Rodriguez Larraín, president of
Lan's Peruvian subsidiary, to explain himself.
Lan apologised in full-page ads in Peruvian newspapers
and sacked those responsible, but Ignacio Walker, Chile's foreign
minister, aggravated tensions by saying Peru was whipping up
a storm in a teacup.
Peru has called off trade talks with Chile, and
a Congressional committee proposes to exclude Chile from investing
in ports and airports. Carlos Ferrero, Peru's prime minister,
has vowed to seek damages from Lan in court.
Lan is promising to make amends by making a new
film that shows the colonial "City of Kings" in all
its splendour. Observer suggests that this time any shots of
tramps relieving themselves be edited out.
Jailed Leader of Police Unit Lays Blame
on Pinochet
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, The New York Times
May 16th
SANTIAGO, Chile, May 14 (AP) - The commander of
the secret police under Gen. Augusto Pinochet said in a court
document that General Pinochet was responsible for abuses committed
by the police, his lawyer said Friday.
The retired commander, Gen. Manuel Contreras,
also submitted a document to the Supreme Court discussing the
fate of more than 500 dissidents who disappeared after being
arrested by his force, said Juan Carlos Manns, General Contreras's
lawyer. The report confirmed that many of the victims were thrown
into the sea after being killed - a disclosure made last year
by a presidential investigative commission.
Mr. Manns said his imprisoned client put the responsibility
for the abuses on General Pinochet and the other military commanders.
In the document, General Contreras said he was writing to counter
"the permanent, ominous silence maintained by my superior,"
referring to General Pinochet.
The government said it would be up to the courts
to determine the accuracy of the information.
General Contreras, 75, commanded the secret service
known as Dina, which is blamed for the worst human rights abuses
during the first years of General Pinochet's dictatorship. He
is serving a 15-year prison term for the assassination of a
dissident. Some other officers in the service are also serving
prison terms.
General Pinochet, who took power in a violent
coup on Sept. 11, 1973, and ruled until 1990, has been indicted
twice, but the trials were stopped by the courts because of
his health.
General Contreras, his law |